Panoramic view at sunset of the embankment and coastline of the River Neches in Beaumont, Texas.

Case Study: How Broad Is Too Broad When Enforcing a Non-Compete Agreement?

Non-compete agreements can be valid and enforceable in Texas, but they must meet certain requirements first: They must be reasonable in scope, duration, and geographic area. These elements are not defined by statute, but rather, a reasonable scope, duration or geographic area depends on the situation. In one recent case decided by the Court of Appeals for the First District of Texas, prohibiting an employee from working anywhere in the state was deemed too broad. The Houston non-compete attorneys at Hendershot Cowart P.C. review the facts and implications of the case

Case Study: When Is a Non-Compete Agreement Unenforceable in Texas?

This case involved a plaster salesman who began working for a Houston-based masonry supplier in October 2007. After working at the company for more than a year, he signed a non-compete agreement which prohibited him from revealing company information or from working for any stucco business anywhere in the state of Texas. If he violated the agreement, the agreement called for liquidated damages of $100 per day.

The plaster salesman’s job was terminated in late December 2009. He then worked as a plaster salesman for another company. In 2012, his previous employer sued the plaster salesman for breaching his non-compete agreement and sought liquidated damages. A district court awarded summary judgment to the plaster salesman on the grounds that the covenant not to compete was overbroad and unenforceable because it covered the entire state of Texas.

The Court of Appeals for the First District of Texas agreed. In a decision issued in May 2014, the court found that the company had the burden to show that it complied with the Covenant Not to Compete Act. It found that the company did not show that compliance. The salesman had testified that the company only did business in Houston, Beaumont, and San Antonio and that he had only handled the Houston and Beaumont areas.

The company provided an affidavit from the company president testifying that the company does business throughout the state and that the salesman had been responsible for sales statewide, but the appellate court rejected that evidence as conclusory. Based on the evidence, the court concluded that it was unreasonable to limit the salesman’s ability to work anywhere in the state of Texas when he had only worked in two cities.

Drafting and Defending Non-Compete Agreements for Texans Since 1987

At Hendershot Cowart P.C., we’ve helped Texans negotiate, draft, implement, enforce, and defend non-compete agreements for more than 30 years. Our lawyers know what it takes to help a business owner draft an airtight non-compete agreement, and we know how to contest a faulty contract in court or through arbitration.

Categories

We Are on Your Side

Contact Us to Schedule Your Consultation
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.