Skip to Content
Top

What Are The Defenses to Trademark Infringement?

Logo and color palette drafts on a desk, showing the brand elements a business may protect with a trademark
|

Reviewed by Daria Adler, Trademark Litigation Attorney, Hendershot Cowart P.C. | Last updated: October 30, 2026

A letter arrives accusing your business of trademark infringement. It says your name, logo, or website is confusingly similar to someone else's brand, and it demands that you stop using it right away – or face a lawsuit.

But a similar name or logo isn’t automatically infringement. A trademark owner can stop only uses that are likely to confuse customers about who is behind a product or service. The trademark owner has to prove its case first and give you the right to defend yourself.

Here's how infringement claims work and the defenses that most often defeat them.

Trademark Infringement Defendants: Understanding Your Case

A trademark is any word, name, symbol, or design – and occasionally a product shape or color – that tells customers who is behind a product or service. Trademarks protect brands, and they protect customers from being misled about who they're buying from.

Trademark owners can sue under the Lanham Act, the federal trademark law, or under Texas state law. Either way, the core question is the same: is your use of the mark likely to confuse customers about the source, sponsorship, or approval of your products or services?

Federal courts in Texas weigh eight factors to answer that question:

  • How strong and distinctive the owner's mark is
  • How similar the two marks look, sound, and feel
  • How similar the products or services are
  • Whether the businesses sell through the same outlets to the same customers
  • Whether they advertise in the same places
  • Whether the accused business intended to trade on the owner's reputation
  • Whether there's evidence of actual customer confusion
  • How carefully customers shop before buying

No single factor decides the case. Using the exact same name on the same type of product is clearly infringement – naming your company "Apple" and selling laptops would confuse almost anyone. Using the same word for something unrelated usually isn't. "Apple Auto Parts" is easy to tell apart from the maker of iPhones.

Most disputes fall somewhere in between, and that's where legal defenses matter most.

Liability and Potential Damages

What the other side must prove depends on the type of claim. Under federal law, the most common claims include:

  • Infringement of a registered mark. If the mark is federally registered, the owner must show that it owns a valid mark, that you used a similar mark in business, and that your use is likely to cause confusion.
  • Unfair competition, also called false designation of origin. Federal law also protects unregistered marks. The owner must prove it has rights in the mark – usually by showing it used the mark first and that customers associate the mark with its business – and that your use is likely to confuse customers about who is behind your products or services, or whether the owner sponsors or approves them.
  • False advertising. A competitor doesn't need to own a trademark to sue over misleading statements about your products or services, or about its own.
  • Dilution. The owner of a famous mark can sue to stop uses that blur the mark's distinctiveness or tarnish its reputation. The mark doesn't have to be registered, and the owner doesn't have to prove that customers are confused.

Texas law offers similar claims, including infringement of a Texas-registered mark, common law trademark infringement and unfair competition, and dilution of a mark that's famous in Texas.

If the other side succeeds, a court may order:

  • An injunction stopping or limiting your use of the mark – sometimes before the case is decided
  • Payment of the owner's actual damages, which a court may increase up to three times in some circumstances
  • In counterfeiting cases involving a federally registered mark, statutory damages instead of actual damages – from $1,000 to $200,000 per counterfeit mark, per type of goods or services, or up to $2 million per mark if the counterfeiting was willful. The owner doesn't have to prove what it actually lost.
  • Payment of the profits you earned from the infringing use
  • Attorneys' fees, but only in exceptional cases and generally in cases of intentional counterfeiting

Two limits work in your favor. Courts don't award profits automatically; they weigh factors such as your intent and whether the owner delayed. And a trademark owner that didn't display the ® registration symbol generally can't recover money damages unless you knew about the registration through other means.

Learn more about legal remedies for trademark infringement.

Trademark Infringement Defense: Affirmative Defenses and More

The right defense depends on the facts. Most defenses challenge one of three things: whether the other side owns the mark, whether the mark is enforceable, and whether confusion is likely.

No Likelihood of Confusion

Strictly speaking, this isn’t an affirmative defense. It’s a challenge to the trademark owner’s case. The owner has the burden to prove that confusion is likely, and the most common way to fight a claim is to show that it can’t. Differences in the products, customers, markets, sales channels, or design of the marks can all weigh against a finding of likely confusion.

Keep in mind that the owner doesn’t have to show that any customer was actually confused – a likelihood of confusion is enough. Evidence of actual confusion can strengthen the owner’s case, but its absence won’t necessarily defeat the claim.

Prior Use

In the U.S., trademark rights generally go to whoever used a mark first, not whoever registered it first. If your business used the name before the other side did, you may have the stronger rights.

The same logic can protect a business that started using a name in good faith in a separate area, where the other business wasn't known. In that case, a court may allow both businesses to keep operating in their own markets. This defense is much narrower if the other side has a federal registration, and it generally isn't available if you started using the mark after that registration issued.

Weak or Invalid Mark

Not every word can be a trademark. A generic term – the common name for a product or service, like "pizza" or “tax consultant” – cannot be protected. A descriptive word, a place name, or a surname generally can't be enforced unless customers have come to associate it with one specific business (often called "secondary meaning").

This defense is harder to win when the mark is federally registered. A registration is presumed valid, so you carry the burden of proving that the mark is invalid. If you succeed, you can ask the court to cancel the registration, and the owner loses the legal advantages it provides.

What you can argue depends on how long the mark has been registered:

  • Within the first five years, you can argue that the mark was never protectable – for example, because it's merely descriptive and lacks secondary meaning – or that it conflicts with a mark you used first.
  • After five years, those arguments are generally no longer available. But at any time, you can still argue that the mark is generic, is functional, has been abandoned, or was registered through fraud.

For an unregistered mark, the owner must prove its mark is valid in the first place.

Abandonment

A trademark owner can lose its rights. A mark is abandoned if the owner stops using it with no intent to resume. Three consecutive years without use creates a presumption of abandonment.

An owner can also abandon a mark by letting it lose its meaning – for example, by licensing it to others without any control over the quality of their products.

Fair Use

Fair use comes in two forms.

Descriptive fair use protects the good-faith use of a word in its ordinary, descriptive sense rather than as a brand. In Sunmark, Inc. v. Ocean Spray Cranberries, Inc. (1995), the maker of SweeTarts candy failed to stop Ocean Spray from describing a juice as "sweet-tart." Ocean Spray was describing the taste, not branding the product.

Nominative fair use protects using another company's mark to refer to that company's own products – in comparison advertising, repair services, resale, or news coverage. You may use only as much of the mark as you need to identify the product, and you can't suggest that the owner sponsors or endorses you.

Parody and Free Expression

Parody, commentary, criticism, and artistic works can be protected. A comedy sketch that mocks a phone company's advertising isn't likely to make anyone think the phone company produced it.

The limits tightened in 2023. In Jack Daniel's Properties, Inc. v. VIP Products LLC (2023), the U.S. Supreme Court considered a dog toy shaped like a Jack Daniel's bottle and labeled "Bad Spaniels." The court held that when a business uses a parody of someone else's mark as its own brand, the usual confusion test applies – the parody gets no special protection. Parody still matters, but it's now one factor in the confusion analysis rather than a shield.

First Sale Doctrine: Reselling Genuine Products

Under what's known as the first sale doctrine, once a trademark owner sells a genuine product, it generally can't stop others from reselling it. Retailers, resellers, and secondhand sellers can usually sell authentic branded goods without the owner's permission. The defense generally doesn't apply if you materially change the product – for example, by replacing parts with non-genuine ones and reselling it under the original brand. Selling an altered product as the genuine article is known as passing off.

The doctrine also doesn't protect the opposite practice, called reverse passing off: buying another company's products, removing its brand, and selling them under your own name – or with no name at all.

Other Trademark Infringement Defenses

Beyond the defenses above, courts recognize defenses based on the trademark owner's own conduct and on the nature of its mark.

Laches

Laches applies when the trademark owner waited an unreasonable time to act and that delay harmed you – for example, because you invested in a name while the owner stayed silent. Federal trademark law has no filing deadline, so federal courts in Texas use Texas’s four-year deadline as a guide. A delay of less than four years is usually considered reasonable. A longer delay makes a laches defense much stronger.

The catch: laches usually limits money damages rather than stopping an injunction, and it generally doesn't protect a business that infringed intentionally.

For a recent example, see how the Texas Stock Exchange used the Toronto Stock Exchange’s delayin its defense.

Acquiescence

Acquiescence applies when the trademark owner actively assured you – by words or conduct – that it wouldn't object to your use, and you relied on that assurance.

Even when the defense applies, it may fail if confusion is inevitable.

Unclean Hands

A court may refuse to help a trademark owner that engaged in misconduct related to the mark it's trying to enforce – for example, using the mark deceptively on its own product labels.

Functionality

A product feature that's essential to how the product works – or that affects its cost or quality – can't be a trademark. This defense comes up most often in disputes over product shapes, packaging, and design.

What to Do If You're Accused of Trademark Infringement

Gather your records – first use dates, marketing materials, registrations, and any contact with the other side – and talk with an attorney before you respond. Many disputes end with a well-supported response letter or a negotiated agreement, without a lawsuit.

At the same time, protect your available defenses by avoiding these actions:

  • Don't ignore the demand letter or lawsuit. Silence can be used to show bad faith, and missing a court deadline can cost you the case.
  • Don't respond on your own. An admission or careless explanation in an email can become evidence.
  • Don't rebrand immediately. Changing everything before you know your rights can cost you a position you didn't need to give up.
  • Don't destroy records. Evidence of when and how you started using your name or logo may be your best defense.

Learn more about responding to a cease-and-desist letter.

If the dispute involves copied written content, photos, or software rather than a name or logo, it may be a copyright infringement issue instead.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most common defense to trademark infringement?

The most common way to fight a claim is to argue that confusion isn't likely. Technically, that's a challenge to the trademark owner's proof rather than an affirmative defense. Because the owner must prove that customers are likely to be confused, differences in products, customers, markets, and design often decide the case.

Can I be sued for trademark infringement if the other company's mark isn't registered?

Yes. Federal and Texas law both protect unregistered marks. But the owner of an unregistered mark must prove it used the mark first and that customers associate it with its business. Its rights traditionally extend only to the area where customers know the mark. But for businesses that sell or advertise online, that area can be much broader than their physical location.

How long does a trademark owner have to sue?

Federal trademark law has no set deadline. Texas federal courts generally look to a four-year period when deciding whether a trademark owner waited too long, and Texas state claims generally follow the same period. Because each day of infringing use can create a new claim, timing defenses rarely end a case on their own.

Speak With a Houston Trademark Infringement Defense Attorney

The outcome of a trademark dispute depends on the details – how and when each mark was used, where the businesses operate, and what customers experienced. The strongest defense often comes from records you already have.

Hendershot Cowart P.C. represents Texas businesses on both sides of trademark disputes, so we know how these claims are built and where they tend to break down. Learn more about our trademark infringement defense attorneys in Houston.

Accused of trademark infringement? Call (713) 783-3110 or contact us online before you respond.