Skip to Content
Top
Compounding Pharmacies

Compounding Pharmacy Fraud Defense

Defense Against False Claims Act and Anti-Kickback Statute Violations

The federal government is intent on eliminating fraud and abuse in the health care industry. This includes aggressive targeting of compounding pharmacies. Compounded medications are customized medications made based on a practitioner’s prescription in which ingredients are mixed together in the strength, dosage, and form required to treat a patient’s specific needs. The federal government is also carefully scrutinizing physicians, pharmacists, executives, marketing companies, and others involved with these pharmacies.

As evidenced by recent investigations and settlements, the federal government is increasing scrutiny over the compounding drug industry, which investigators believe is rife with fraud and abuse. Although allegations of fraudulent practices extend throughout the industry, including Medicare and Medicaid, the government has paid particular attention to TRICARE, a government program for military health insurance that paid $1.75 billion for compounded drugs in FY 2015 alone.

Compounding Pharmacy Fraud Investigations

In response to such a substantial spike in TRICARE costs, federal authorities are now aggressively investigating fraudulent schemes, including potential false claims, kickback arrangements, and improper auto-refill programs. Typically, these schemes operate through the use of aggressive marketing tactics that obtain patient authorization for physicians to write prescriptions that are sent to a compounding pharmacy, often without a patient ever meeting or speaking to a doctor.

In addition to citing lack of medical necessity and failure to establish physician-patient relationships as a basis for False Claims Act (FCA) violations, the federal government also claims that compounding pharmacies routinely over-bill federal payors to provide incentives and other kickback arrangements to doctors who agree to write prescriptions, in violation of the federal Anti-Kickback Statute (AKS).

Investigations to identify alleged fraud and abuse under the FCA and AKS involve:

  • Data mining to identify increases in prescriptions for a particular compounding drug when there is a commercially available drug which serves the same purpose
  • Physicians who prescribe high amounts of pain creams, scar creams, and wrinkle creams. These include orthopedic surgeons, podiatrists, spine surgeons, pain management specialists, sports medicine doctors, chiropractors, and physician assistants
  • Prescribing physicians who receive compensation from compounding pharmacies through medical director fees, speaking fees, and profit distribution
  • Fraud committed against TRICARE and other federal payors, including Medicaid and Medicare
  • Arrangements involving a high percentage of out-of-state physicians prescribing medications
  • Unauthorized or automatic refills
  • Evaluations of telemedicine protocol in absence of true physician-patient relationships

How Compounding Pharmacies Can Violate the False Claims Act or Anti-Kickback Statute

  • False Claims Act – Many of the federal investigations into compounding pharmacies arise out of the False Claims Act, which prohibits the presentation of a false or fraudulent claim for approval, or false records or statements, to defraud the federal government. FCA violations can result in a civil penalty between $5,000 to $10,000 per claim, as well as a sanction up to 3 times the amount of damages (treble damages) sustained by the government.
  • Anti-Kickback Statute – The Anti-Kickback Statute (AKS) makes it a felony to knowingly and willfully solicit, offer, pay, or receive remuneration in exchange for the referral of federal health care program business. Convictions are punishable by fines (up to $25,000 for a single violation), imprisonment (up to 5 years for a single violation), and exclusion from federal health care programs, as well as potential civil monetary penalties, including treble damages plus $50,000 for each violation.

Under the False Claims Act and Anti-Kickback Statute, multiple parties involved with compounding pharmacies can face prosecution for their involvement in an alleged fraudulent scheme. 

For example, government authorities may allege:

  • A marketing company violated the AKS by providing physicians unlawful kickbacks
  • Physicians violated the AKS by issuing prescriptions without meeting standards of telemedicine
  • Compounding pharmacies violated the AKS by providing kickbacks to physicians who write compound medication prescriptions with claims submitted to a federal payor
  • Pharmacies fraudulently billed TRICARE or other federal payors

Compounding & Telemedicine

As federal authorities allege that many schemes operate without establishing proper doctor-patient relationships, they must investigate whether proper telemedicine protocol was followed. Telemedicine can be legal when it constitutes a proper doctor-patient relationship, treatment is medically necessary, and all the following components are met:

  1. Physician establishes the person requesting treatment is in fact who the person claims to be;
  2. An appropriate diagnosis is established by the physician through the use of acceptable medical practices; and
  3. The physician discusses the diagnosis and evidence of diagnosis with the patient in person at an established medical site.

Investigators may also look closely at marketing representatives, including sales reps and others hired to promote compound medications, who relay symptoms to the telemedicine doctor, who then sends the prescription to the compounding pharmacy – especially if they are paid on a percentage of prescriptions they generate. 

If the initial contract with the marketing company was not a proper contract, and there was a kickback included, then every resulting prescription can be considered tainted, and all claims submitted to a federal health care program for reimbursement subject to being in violation of the AKS.

Pharmacy / Physician Kickback and Health Care Fraud Defense

Investigations are being waged in Texas and other states across the country by the Department of Defense (DOD), Department of Justice (DOJ), Health and Human Services Office of the Inspector General (OIG), State Attorney General, and, to some degree, the FDA and DEA. Depending on the nature of the allegations, structure of companies, and other individual facts, there may be a number of viable defense strategies, including:

  • Intent – The AKS is an intent-based statute, which means not every remuneration from a compounding pharmacy to a prescribing doctor is a violation. As long as no “one purpose” of such remuneration is to induce referrals, there may be a defense that no violation occurred. The False Claims Act also requires intent to submit a false claim or improper bill. Because there does not have to be an intent to violate the law in order for conduct to be considered a violation, there is a very fine line when proving a lack of intent to defraud.
  • Safe Harbors – “Safe Harbors” can protect certain businesses from civil and criminal prosecution, provided they can be considered certain types of arrangements, including personal services and management contracts. If a prescribing doctor is paid by a compounding pharmacy to speak about its products at events and conferences, that relationship may fall under the personal services safe harbor if all requirements are met (i.e. an agreement of at least 1 year in writing that has been signed by the parties and covers all services to be provided, and compensation that is set in advance, consistent with fair market value, and does not take volume or value of referrals into account).
  • Medical Necessity – Federal health care programs only pay for medically necessary services and products, which means billing for things that are medically unnecessary is a violation of the FCA. If a proper doctor-patient relationship was established, and physicians appropriately determined patients truly needed specially-made medications, then a defense can be raised to show medical necessity and proper compliance with telemedicine requirements. This may also involve proving that proper protocol for telemedicine were met.

Compounding pharmacies, physicians, and others may be notified of an investigation when they receive a civil investigative demand (CID) from the federal government, which requests documentation in regard to possible violations of the False Claims Act. These include documents pertaining to company records, financials, marketing agreements, physician relationships, and medical records. Investigations may also begin with a subpoena or unannounced visits from a federal agent.

Although a CID can trigger many concerns, including concerns over costs, there are steps that can be taken to reduce the scope of documents demanded in the CID, which can dramatically reduce time and expenses required in a response. For example, our team focuses on effectively interpreting the CID and facilitating discussions with federal prosecutors, who are often open to good faith negotiations about providing the government with the evidence it needs without the disproportionate financial expenses companies may incur in producing non-critical information. Such discussions can also facilitate potential resolutions and mitigated penalties.

Compounding Fraud Investigation? Discuss Your Case During an Initial Consultation

If you have been made aware of an investigation or have concerns over a potential investigation, you need to act immediately. At Hendershot Cowart P.C., we have extensive experience defending physicians and health care practices accused of fraud and abuse, and leverage over 150 years of combined experience to provide the counsel and aggressive representation required when clients face investigations and allegations.

To discuss a potential case and how our award-winning health care attorneys can help, call (713) 783-3110.

Why Choose Our Team?

Unwavering Commitment to the Success of our Clients

With decades of combined experience, we bring big-firm capability with personal firm service.

  • In Business Since 1987.

    Nearly 40 years representing clients in business and healthcare matters.

  • We Serve Clients Throughout Texas and the Nation.
    We handle matters from the Red River to the Rio Grande and beyond.
  • We Build It, and We Defend It.

    We form Texas businesses and medical practices, and we defend them when regulators, payers, partners, or outside parties come calling.

  • Legal Counsel You Can Understand.

    We explain every step in plain English and lay out our fee arrangement up front, before you sign anything.

  • We Want to Be Your Law Firm for Life.™
    We take a vested interest in our clients' success – from start to finish.

To Us, Every Case is Personal

Real Stories, Real Results, Real Advocacy
    "Mandie truly cared about us and the outcome of our hearing."
    Exceptional law practice!! Their team was very responsive to all of our questions and concerns. The attention to detail and the research they did to help fight our case was top notch. Our lawyer, Mandie Eichenlaub and her incredible team was attentive, and thorough in every aspect of our case. Mandie truly cared about us and the outcome of our hearing. We will be forever loyal to this law practice and highly recommend them to anyone wanting reliable representation.
    - Heather N.
    "Invaluable to have their counsel."
    The HC team is exceptional. I worked with Keith, Patrick and Lauren - they were an amazing team and extremely comprehensive. I had 6 total Agreements I was negotiating in the healthcare space that spanned from Operating Agreements, Joint Venture, Development (territory rights and schedule), and a Franchise Agreement, and Managements Service Agreements. Also need to form new entities, and structure investor documents. Their expertise spanned legal, business, and the healthcare regulatory environment. Invaluable to have their counsel. I highly recommend the team at HC Law.
    - Scott S.
    "I am incredibly grateful to the entire team for protecting my career"
    I received exceptional legal representation by Hendershot Cowart P.C., and specifically by Brady Dunlop.

    Throughout the process, Brady was patient, tireless, and highly strategic in developing a solid defense. His guidance and expertise were invaluable, ultimately leading to a smooth dismissal of the case.

    As someone deeply dedicated to the field of medicine, these allegations were personally distressing. I am incredibly grateful to the entire team for protecting my career and resolving this matter so effectively. Thank you.
    - Jenni B.
    "It was a delight to finally get an attorney on the phone that seemed to know the exact steps that we needed to take."
    I’m very pleased with the outcome so far with this law firm, from the initial contact with their intake and how polite they were documenting everything that we talked about. The knowledge that they had was just great. Laura Vacker called me within the day to go over everything, She was extremely helpful. She broke down everything and gave me as much information on the law firm that could be provided. Most law firms don’t even do that. She gave me different options, which I am reviewing now. It was a delight to finally get an attorney on the phone that seemed to know the exact steps that we needed to take.
    - Patrick B.
    "We will be back for all future legal needs."
    I highly recommend Hendershot Cowart and specifically Philip. He helped us on a very complicated property dispute that ended in our favor. It was clear from the start that he is motivated and genuinely cares about his clients. We will be back for all future legal needs.
    - Zachary H.
    "I'm glad to know I always have top-notch legal representation"
    I have worked with Trey and the team there multiple times. They are attentive, great to work with, and I'm glad to know I always have top-notch legal representation
    - Brad B.
    "Keith was able to get our business up and running again."

    Great people to work with! Keith helped us through our appeal step by step and was able to get our business up and running again.

    "I don't believe we could have navigated this challenging situation without his support."

    Highly recommend the firm and Philip in particular; I greatly appreciate the firm for the invaluable assistance with the legal matters we engaged it to address. Philip Racusin's expertise, attentiveness, responsiveness, and professionalism have been exceptional, and I don't believe we could have navigated this challenging situation without his support.

We Are On Your Side Contact Us to Schedule Your Consultation

Call (713) 783-3110 or submit our online contact form. An attorney or member of our reception team will contact you to discuss your matter.

Fill Out The Form
Or
Call Us Today 713-783-3110
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please enter a message.